Volcanoes | suyts space

Many people in the climate discussion refer to volcanoes.  They are used on both sides of the discussion.  They are often seen as an aberration of our climate, in that they cause things to happen which would not otherwise occur, in both the short and long run.  I disagree.  I believe they are every bit of the natural part of our climate and that large eruptions have very little effect on our climate.  More specifically our global temp anomaly.  Volcanoes, in some part of this world are always erupting.  I should point out there are various types and subtypes of volcanoes.  For today’s purposes, I’m not making any distinction.  Today I want to examine the temp responses to the large eruptions of the last century.  The criteria I will use is the VEI.  We will examine the volcanoes of the last century with a VEI of 5 or 6.  There were no 7 or greater.  The Tropospheric injection and
Stratospheric injection are described as “substantial“.

Here is the listing of 5-6 volcanic eruptions last century.

           6 Santa Maria 1902
5 Ksudach 1907
6 Novarupta 1912
5 Colima 1913
5 Cerro Azul 1932
5 Kharimkotan 1933
5 Bezymianny 1956
5 Mount Agung 1963
5 Mount St. Helens 1980
5 El Chichon 1982
6 Mount Pinatubo 1991
5 Mount Hudson 1991

Starting with Santa Maria of 1902 see a slight drop of 0.2°C over a 3 year period of time.  Then things continue as they were.

image

image

For Ksudach, we can’t really tell, the temps went down and then up and then down again, so we’re not certain about the effects of time but at most it can be described as causing a          -0.3°C change over 4 years.

image

Novarupta didn’t seem to have much of any effect…. if it did the time it did was very short. and the Colima had the inverse if at all.

image

Again we have two volcanoes and a very negligible effect.  Cerro Azul could have caused a  -0.4°C decline over 2 years, but then Kharimkotan would then have had zero effect.

image

Here we have a WTF? moment. Bezymianny erupted over the period of time covering 55-57.  And the temps responded by increasing by about 0.6°C.

image

Mount Agung has a near equal and opposite response!!!!

image

Okay, so Mt. St. Helens effect was negligible.  But, the temps cooled after Chichon.

1991 marked a year in which there were two significant eruptions.  Mount Pinatubo, and the less famous Mount Hudson.

image

One would have thought we would have seen a very strong signal with a 5 and a 6 occurring in the same year.  But, temps started to climb in 1993.

Contrast these to other known climatic variations…….

image

The El Nino of 1998 had a temp response of a positive 0.6°C and the 2007-2008 La Nina had a temp response of -0.5°C.  There is no compelling reason to believe volcanic eruptions of the 5-6 magnitude significantly alters any temp anomaly for any real duration.  And they don’t seem to be outside the normal variations of just regular every year temp anomalies.  We looked at 12 eruptions.  Two of them the temps responded by increasing.  Another’s effect seemed null.  The most recent two didn’t cause anything outside normal variation in spite of occurring within the same year.

 

Read more

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Grist

A nonprofit news org for people who want a planet that doesn’t burn and a future that doesn’t suck.

My Planet Earth

Creating a Healthy Planet

Planet Earth Weekly

Climate Change and Renewable Energy: Saving Our Planet for Future Generations

Follow The Money

"It has to start somewhere. It has to start sometime. What better place than here? What better time than now?"

Pedal and Plow

Cycling across South America to to discover what agriculture can be

BE CURIOUS

The important thing is not to stop questioning. Curiosity has it's own reason for existing.

patricktsudlow

Patrick Sudlow's blog

The Common Constitutionalist - Let The Truth Be Known

Politics, current events, human interest & some humor

Midwest Naturalist

Living in harmony with our creator, his creation and all living things.

You Evolving

Science, Adventure, Philosophy, Personal Evolution

Road To Abundance

The Earth Is Full and There is More Than Enough to Spare

Seaspout

Ocean News & Views

Coal Action Network Aotearoa

Keep the Coal in the Hole!

Precarious Climate

A call for urgent action on climate change

The GOLDEN RULE

“During times of universal deceit, telling the truth becomes a revolutionary act” – George Orwell

Earth Report

Global Disaster Watch - An Overview

The Survival Place Blog

Surviving The World As We Know It

manchester climate monthly

To inform, inspire and involve

DeepResource

Observing the world of renewable energy and sustainable living

%d bloggers like this: